Do pages with a manual indexing request really get impressions sooner?
There are hints, but nothing we can prove. We split the 83 new pages launched on or before 2026-11-09 into two groups: 17 pages our operations log marks as “requested indexing”, of which 9 already have impressions recorded in Search Console, and 66 that relied on the sitemap alone, of which 14 do. The median gap from launch day to first impressions is 0 days for the requested pages and 2 days for the others. But which pages we requested was not random, and the dashboard stores only the top slice of URLs by impressions each day, so the two groups cannot simply be subtracted.
| Site | Requested: pages | Requested: with impressions | Not requested: pages | Not requested: with impressions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gamma AI Slide | 7 | 6 | 26 | 11 |
| kagentx | 9 | 2 | 37 | 1 |
| MochiStamp | 1 | 1 | 3 | 2 |
| Total | 17 | 9 | 66 | 14 |
Source: the Google Search Console page table in our local dashboard and the growth-ops page log, read on 2026-11-13; only new pages launched on or before 11-09 are counted, not deepened older pages; the latest day in the page table is 11-12 (11-11 for kagentx). Pagent has no page-level search data and is not included.
How many days until the first impressions?
Among pages that have impressions, 6 of the 9 requested pages have a record on launch day, while only 1 of the 14 others does; most of the rest took 1 to 2 days, and the longest took 3.
| First impression record, days after launch | Requested (9 pages) | Not requested (14 pages) |
|---|---|---|
| 0 days | 6 | 1 |
| 1 day | 1 | 5 |
| 2 days | 2 | 6 |
| 3 days | 0 | 2 |
| Median | 0 days | 2 days |
| Total impressions on record | 56 | 113 |
“Launch day” is the date on that row of the operations log; indexing requests usually went in on launch day or the day after, and we did not record the exact time.
For pages launched the same day, how big is the gap?
This is the cleanest comparison, but the sample is small. Gamma AI Slide launched 14 pages on 2026-11-09: 6 of the 7 requested pages had impressions before 11-12, against only 1 of the 7 that were not.
| Gamma pages launched 2026-11-09 | Pages | With impressions |
|---|---|---|
| Requested | 7 | 6 |
| Not requested | 7 | 1 |
| Of which English pages: requested | 6 | 6 |
| Of which English pages: not requested | 3 | 1 |
Four of the 7 pages we did not request are Japanese and Simplified Chinese pages, so “requested” and “English” are mixed together: English pages tend to get impressions first anyway. Comparing English pages only, it is 6 of 6 against 1 of 3; the difference is still there, but 3 pages are only 3 pages.
A counterexample: of the 5 English Gamma pages launched on 11-06 and not requested, 3 had impressions before 11-08, so sitemap alone can also get a page to impressions within two days.
Why can we see no difference on kagentx?
For the 6 kagentx guides launched on 11-05 and requested on 11-06, the dashboard's page table has no record of those URLs through 11-11; of the 37 pages we did not request, only 1 has a record. The kagentx page table holds only about 4 URLs a day, so most pages would not make it into the table even if they had impressions. That kagentx row (2 of 9 against 1 of 37) shows only that volumes are small, not whether requesting helps.
Does this prove requesting indexing is faster?
No. Four reasons:
- We chose which pages to request by priority rather than at random, and the pages left to the sitemap were whatever remained after the quota ran out.
- Languages are mixed: the requested pages are mostly English, while the rest are more often Japanese or Chinese.
- The dashboard keeps only the top 25 or so URLs by impressions each day, so no record does not mean no impressions.
- Search Console data for the last day or two is incomplete, and very new pages have no data yet; see How many days is Search Console data behind? Why are the latest days low?.
All our data can say is that requested pages appear earlier in the records, and that the 14 pages we did not request but that have impressions also appeared within 3 days. To prove it you would need a test where pages launch the same day in the same language and half are chosen at random to be requested; we have not run one.
What does Google officially say?
| Source (checked 2026-11-13) | What it says |
|---|---|
| Google Search Central: Ask Google to recrawl your URLs | A crawl request is not guaranteed to show up quickly, or at all; a recrawl can take a few days to a few weeks; there is a quota for submitting individual URLs; if you have many URLs, submit a sitemap; requesting the same URL repeatedly does not make it faster |
So the official position is that a request is not priority indexing, and a sitemap is the right way to get many URLs discovered. For how many requests you can submit a day, see How many "Request indexing" can you submit a day? 14 rounds of records over 10 days, and what happened after.
When is a manual request worth it?
1. First make sure the page is in the sitemap and lastmod is true
Put new pages in the sitemap and set lastmod to the date the page really changed; this is the baseline that works for every page. For setting up a new site, see How do you get a new website indexed by Google? How many indexing requests can you send a day?.
2. Spend the quota on pages you most want to see impressions early
For example a new page aimed at one particular query, or a page you just overhauled. The number you can submit a day is limited; see How many "Request indexing" can you submit a day? 14 rounds of records over 10 days, and what happened after.
3. Do not request the same page twice
Google states that repeated requests do not make it faster; for an already indexed page whose content merely changed, another request is at most a recrawl request.
4. Check back after a few days, not the same day
Search Console data lags by a day or two; if a page is still not indexed after two weeks, work through the statuses in “Discovered – currently not indexed”: what to do? Discovered vs Crawled.
On the Bing side the mechanism is IndexNow; whether it gets pages crawled sooner is covered in Does IndexNow work? MochiStamp pushes after every deploy: how many pages Bing crawled and how many clicks it sent.
What are the limits of these numbers?
- Only 83 pages, from three sites, launched between 11-05 and 11-09, with the latest data from 11-12; the sample is small and this is not a rule.
- “Requested” and “not requested” come from notes in the operations log, and we did not check the submission time page by page.
- The page table stores only a slice of the URLs with the most impressions each day, so pages with very few impressions have no record; this is especially visible for kagentx.
- There is no randomised comparison, and we did not check whether Google had already indexed a page before the dashboard recorded it.
On the Bing side, how far crawled and indexed counts are from the sitemap page count is in How far apart are Bing's crawled and indexed counts? Crawled, indexed and sitemap pages for three sites.
FAQ
Does requesting indexing get a page impressions faster?
In our data the requested pages show impressions earlier (median 0 days against 2), but which pages we requested was not random and languages are mixed, so it proves nothing. Google only says a request is not guaranteed to show up quickly, or at all.
What is the difference between requesting indexing and a sitemap?
A request tells Google “please crawl this one URL”, and has a daily quota; a sitemap hands Google the whole site's URLs and suits large numbers of pages. Google recommends a sitemap for sites with many URLs.
How long until a page I did not request gets impressions?
Of our 14 pages that were not requested but have impressions, most showed up within 1 to 2 days and the longest took 3; the other 52 unrequested pages have no record in the dashboard, which does not mean they had no impressions.
Can I request the same URL more than once?
You can, but it does not help. Google's documentation states that requesting the same URL repeatedly does not make it get crawled faster.
If an indexed page changes, do I need to request again?
Not every time. You can request once for a page with a large change that you want recrawled sooner; for MochiStamp's deepened older pages we mostly requested a recrawl and left the rest to the sitemap once the quota ran out.
Sources
- Google · Ask Google to recrawl your URLs (checked 2026-11-13)
- Gamma AI Slide · Search Console page data, Nov 2026 (Local data dashboard, read 2026-11-13)
- kagentx · Search Console page data, Nov 2026 (Local data dashboard, read 2026-11-13)
- kagentx evaluations: the data on the case study pages; each example gives its date.