What is Show HN actually for?
Hacker News's official Show HN guidelines page (read 2026-11-07; the page carries no date) is quite specific. The core: it must be something others can try themselves.
| Rule | Official meaning (our paraphrase) |
|---|---|
| Allowed | Things people can run on their own computers or hold in their hands; for hardware, a video or detailed article; for books, a sample chapter |
| Not allowed | Blog posts, sign-up pages, newsletters, lists and other reading-only material; these should be regular submissions |
| Project requirements | Not a quickly generated one-off; you made it yourself and will be around to discuss it; explain how and why you made it |
| Interface | It need not be complicated or slick, and early stage is fine; ideally no barriers such as sign-ups or emails |
| Not ready | Do not post; come back once it is ready. Do not post landing pages or fundraisers |
| Title | Starts with “Show HN” |
| Version updates | “Foo 1.3.1 is out” is generally not enough; a major overhaul may be fine |
| Vote asking | Do not ask friends to upvote or comment. The general guidelines also say not to solicit upvotes or comments |
For indie developers building sites and tools, the easiest traps are the “landing page” and the “sign-up barrier”: if people must sign up before they can try it, or your product is only a page of marketing copy, it does not count as a Show HN under the rules.
Can AI crawlers read Hacker News pages?
We saw no AI-specific restrictions, but one thing needs care. On 2026-11-07 we read HN's robots.txt directly and opened a thread page:
| Item | Result | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| robots.txt | Under the general group: Crawl-delay of 30 seconds; the disallowed paths are action URLs such as /vote?, /reply?, /flag? and /login; there are no separate rules for GPTBot, ClaudeBot or PerplexityBot | The thread page itself is not blocked by robots.txt |
| A Show HN thread page (requested as a browser) | About 436KB; the title is “post title | Hacker News”; the title link points straight to the external URL with no rel attribute on it; all 323 comments are in the HTML; there is a canonical and no meta description | The text is rendered on the server, not by scripts; comment text is in the page too |
| Requests using crawler User-Agent strings (from our machine, not a crawler IP) | PerplexityBot and Perplexity-User returned 200; GPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, ClaudeBot, Googlebot and bingbot returned 419 (the body was only “Sorry”) | Googlebot was refused too, which suggests HN mostly verifies that requests claiming to be crawlers come from official IPs, so this test cannot show that a real GPTBot is refused |
The third row is a warning, not a conclusion: testing with curl by using a crawler's name is unreliable for sites that verify the source. Whether real crawlers read your pages must be checked in server logs. We found no verifiable data on how much HN threads make up of ChatGPT or Perplexity answers, so we give no percentage. What we can confirm: the pages are public, the text is rendered in the HTML, and the thread contains your URL.
Which pages should I prepare on my site before a Show HN?
A HN thread page itself holds only the title and link you wrote, plus comments. What visitors, and the AI that reads it, ultimately see is the page your link points to. So prepare these:
1. An entry point that can be tried without signing up
The rules say ideally no barriers such as sign-ups or emails. What can be tried is the link target, not a landing page.
2. A first screen that says what it is, who it is for and the price
People from HN judge quickly, and the AI reads this same screen. For how to write it, see How to write content AI will quote: before and after.
3. A page on “how it was made and why”
The rules ask you to explain how and why. Write it as an article on your own site and link it from your first comment; this is the page that will be cited again and again later.
4. An honest comparison page
The most common comment is probably “how is this different from X”. Write it as a page in advance and paste the link when asked. For how to write it, see How to write comparison pages.
5. Pricing and limits written as text
The comments will ask about pricing, where data goes and whether it is open source. Put it on the page, not only in comments, which sink.
6. Confirm crawlers are not blocked by your own site
However many mentions HN brings, it does not help if pages cannot be read. Check robots.txt with AI crawler check; how to write it is in How to write robots.txt for AI crawlers.
7. Give links a fixed source parameter
Only then can you recognise these visitors in GA4; the method is in How do you see ChatGPT traffic in GA4?.
After posting, how do I get AI to remember me?
1. Stay in the thread and answer questions
The rules ask you to be around for the discussion. When a reply needs a citation, paste a page on your own site rather than writing it only in a comment.
2. Turn good comment questions into an FAQ page
The questions asked most in the comments are your buyers' real wording. Turn them into Q&A on your site, using the question as the heading and answering it in the first paragraph.
3. Ask AI the same questions after a few weeks
Ask 3 times, count how often you appear and which URLs are in the sources. How to record is in How do you measure AI visibility? Four metrics and a table you can follow.
How do Product Hunt and Reddit differ from this?
| Channel | Core of the rules | Where to find what this guide lacks |
|---|---|---|
| Show HN | Only things people can try themselves, no vote asking, the author must be present | This guide |
| Product Hunt | Launch day is a burst of exposure; product page and /alternatives/ page structure | See: Does a Product Hunt launch help SEO and AI search? |
| Community posts are often cited by AI; answer honestly under your real identity | See: Why do AI answers love citing Reddit? |
Entry points to the other two: Does a Product Hunt launch help SEO and AI search?, Why do AI answers love to cite Reddit? What product teams can and shouldn't do.
FAQ
What are the Show HN rules?
Only post things people can try themselves; no blog posts, sign-up pages, newsletters, lists, landing pages or fundraisers; the project must not be a quickly generated one-off; the title starts with Show HN; do not ask friends to upvote or comment. Source: HN's official Show HN guidelines page (read 2026-11-07).
Can I post a landing page as a Show HN?
No. The guidelines say not to post landing pages or fundraisers; sign-up pages do not count either, since others cannot try the thing first.
Are HN threads cited by ChatGPT or Perplexity?
We found no verifiable data, so this is unverified. What we can confirm: HN's robots.txt has no AI-crawler rules, and the thread text and comments are in the HTML.
Why does requesting HN with a GPTBot User-Agent via curl return 419?
We requested HN from our machine using crawler User-Agent strings: GPTBot, ClaudeBot and even Googlebot returned 419, while PerplexityBot returned 200. Googlebot was refused too, which suggests HN mostly verifies the source IP, so this test says nothing about how real crawlers are treated.
Can friends upvote my post?
No. The Show HN guidelines say not to ask friends to upvote or comment, and the general guidelines say not to solicit upvotes.
Sources
- Hacker News · Show HN Guidelines (Read 2026-11-07; the page carries no date)
- Hacker News · Hacker News Guidelines (Read 2026-11-07; the page carries no date)
- Hacker News · robots.txt (Read 2026-11-07)
- Hacker News · Example thread page (used to inspect the HTML) (Opened 2026-11-07)
- kagentx evaluations: the data on the case study pages; each example gives its date.